NAS 2m HULL-SAR trading system

Forums ProRealTime English forum ProOrder support NAS 2m HULL-SAR trading system

  • This topic has 343 replies, 42 voices, and was last updated 1 year ago by avatarbege.
Viewing 15 posts - 286 through 300 (of 344 total)
  • #167903

    Hello, this week was very bad for 5.5l in the short market in live mode. One should perhaps stick to a long and short variant. I am testing the 1min NAS 7.5 again, in any case 5.5l does not work if the market turns short in the long term, which is starting soon or is already there. nice weekend

    #168042

    this week was very bad for 5.5l

    Hi, the “L” of V5.5L is for “Long” trade. So it means it’s a good code for long trade only. You can backtest it to observe the results for short and long rates.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    #168079

    Hello, yes i know it’s very good code. I just wanted to say that when the market goes short, what I think will happen soon, the code shouldn’t be used anymore. If you switch the code to long and short, short runs at a loss. Maybe someone has an idea how to get this under control?

    #168502

    Here’s the itf

    Hello Noetheless,

     

    I would like to know how you manage the optimization of a code. I mean you can’t walk forward all variable same time with large min / max variable so i would like to know how you manage it.

    Thanks

    #168504

    I optimize 2 or 3 variables at a time, at first with large steps for a rough cut, then finer steps once I know what the range is going to be. Or I’ll do 4 – 6 at once, around 3000 iterations and let it run overnight.

    I would usually do a rough cut on 100% of data so I can see and compare the results, but I don’t always take the top line (highest gain). If profit is similar I’d rather have a higher % win of more trades, or lower drawdown. Then I run a 70/30 WF with finer steps.

    Hope this helps!

    4 users thanked author for this post.
    #168664

    Thanks for your answer,

     

    What about when there are MTF ? Do you test lower TF and add higher TF step by step ? There are often too much variables with these sorts of code.

     

    What is “WF” in : Then I run a 70/30 WF with finer steps.

     

    You use 100% data so you mean 1M barres ?

     

    Thanks, it helps a lot in the way to test codes

    #168669

    What about when there are MTF ? Do you test lower TF and add higher TF step by step ?

    ———When I first developed it I optimized the higher TFs separately to get a longer backtest, but now that I’m fairly confident that it works I do everything on the 2min TF, about 6 years backtest.

    What is “WF” in : Then I run a 70/30 WF with finer steps.   You use 100% data so you mean 1M barres ?

    ———WF meaning Walk Forward, but just using one repetition, about 18 months out of sample. Yes, 100% means 1m bars.

     

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    #168705

    Thanks for your answers 🙂

    #169230

    Good morning everyone,

     

    I am running  NAS Hull SAR v5.5L in demo and I’ve noticed that it opened positions on may 5th and 6th, but when the positions became positive enough to activate de TS, it did not trigger so I stopped the orders manually, did someone have the same issue?

    Moreover, I also tried to BT and it does not return any operation since april 6th (see image attached), does someone have an explanation for that? I also try to BT 10k bars and PRT says its out of date and does not perform the BT.

     

    Thanks everyone in advance!

     

     

    #169238

    Same here, somehow it changed some variables values when going from backtest into preparation for auto trading. Look at “tss”, mine was set at 3.2 instead of 0.2

     

    #169242

    In my case tss variable was correctly set at 0.2. Do you also have the same issue with the BT since april 6th?

    #169247

    No, bt running ok..

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    #169281

    tss = trailingpercentshort

    as this is running long only, it’s irrelevant.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    #169602

    Hiya everyone, today the system opened a position without setting stop loss/take profit. I’m trying to figure out why but am quite clueless.

     

    #169629

    Try commenting out lines 150-151, then adding these lines at line 154:

     

    4 users thanked author for this post.
Viewing 15 posts - 286 through 300 (of 344 total)

Create your free account now and post your request to benefit from the help of the community
Register or Login