intraday DAX strategy 5min mini1€ spread 1

Viewing 15 posts - 286 through 300 (of 503 total)

← 1 2 3 … 19 20 21 … 32 33 34 →

Author

Posts
01/30/2017 at 10:14 AM #23034 quote

CN
Participant

Senior

That is correct @alco, confirmed 4 trades, 3 wins, live.

Alco thanked this post

01/30/2017 at 10:39 AM #23040 quote

4everTrading
Participant

Senior

Hello all

Yep, same results for me in live account. I am on V3 version adapt for 1k as initial capital.

The result below

data.png

01/30/2017 at 10:44 AM #23043 quote

Raul Vg
Participant

Senior

Good morning, could anyone check if the result of today’s backtest is similar to what happened in real? I’m not on the pc right now, thanks.

01/30/2017 at 10:49 AM #23045 quote

mamio
Participant

Veteran

@Raul. Backtest was not similar to real trade, today. 9:00 bar had no trades in real (price was not touched), but in demo there was one little loss. Also real prices are different from demo ones.

01/30/2017 at 10:58 AM #23046 quote

mamio
Participant

Veteran

Also in real account there are trades shown in the chart that didn’t took place in the account itself.

chart-from-real-account.jpg real2.jpg demo.jpg

01/30/2017 at 10:59 AM #23051 quote

mamio
Participant

Veteran

PS I’m using v2 with nn=1

01/30/2017 at 11:01 AM #23053 quote

4everTrading
Participant

Senior

Good mornin Raul,

I just try the same code i used for my live account in the demo account, the backtest result was different, using exactly the same code

Attach bellow

Demo-1.png live.png DAX-5-MIN-v3-small.itf

01/30/2017 at 11:22 AM #23060 quote

Aloysius
Participant

Veteran

@Paris75, an indicator as trailing stop is not as safe, because the system watch this indicator at the begining of the following bar, so in a 5 min UT, the position risks to close 5 minutes after the line is crossed, and that could generate big losses.

01/30/2017 at 12:15 PM #23068 quote
GraHal
Participant

Master
For information / reference …
1. Raul v3 on DEMO TRADE with TS at 6 points … spreadbet 30 Jan, 4 wins see attached.
2. Raul v3 on BACKTEST with TS at 6 points … spreadbet 30 Jan, different results, see attached.
GraHal

Raul-v3-30-jan-.jpg Raul-V3-backtest-.jpg
01/30/2017 at 12:33 PM #23073 quote

Paris
Participant

Veteran

ok good result to day .

Don t really understand why real and demo are not the same , same code and tick by tick ?

01/30/2017 at 12:43 PM #23076 quote

GraHal
Participant

Master

Attached are the Backtest Trades re GraHal last message above for 30 Jan.

Crazy difference …

Demo Forward Test Trades £504 profit Today 30 Jan

Backtest Trades £15 profit Today 30 Jan.

GraHal

Raul-V3-backtest-Orders-.jpg Raul-v3-backtest-results.jpg

01/30/2017 at 3:50 PM #23096 quote

Lyny
Participant

Junior

what happen? It is a lot differences for me!!! Real live today, trade 1, cancelled, trade 2 at 8:15 win £15, end of the story. on demo account, it seems happen a lot of of rejected order: Trailing stop distance was lower than the minimum required (i set trailing stop 5), and only 1 trade, win of £6.

Crazy??? ( I start trade with 2 points)

result-dax-v3-real-ac-30jan.png order-dax-v3-real-ac-30Jan.png dax-v3-real-ac-30Jan.png dax-v3-demo-ac-30Jan.png

01/30/2017 at 4:21 PM #23102 quote

Lyny
Participant

Junior

with £10000 capital, for DAX v3 run ok, what number should i fill in the Max Position Size on the attached picture below? Any advice?

max-position-size-DAX.png

01/30/2017 at 7:30 PM #23135 quote

Raul Vg
Participant

Senior

Hello! I’ve been looking at the differences between the real and the backtest, to the left what happened in demo, right on the backtest. Is of the version v2, in demo wins and in the backtest loses. In real it has not worked because yesterday I was wrong to put it.

We see that in the demo, in the first operation, the stop is skipped, closing at -13 points, probably due to a fast movement.

In the second image we see what happened tick by tick, you see, as the second operation does not put it at 9.05h but it puts it at 9.07

The others put them when they should.

today-1.png today-2.png

01/30/2017 at 7:33 PM #23139 quote

GraHal
Participant

Master

@Lyny What number did you enter for Lot size re your Live Trades today?

On Demo Forward Test (spreadbet) a TS of 5 gets rejected by IG on most occasions? I had several ‘Raul versions’ running in Demo… all those with TS of 5 were rejected and the ATS QUIT, those with TS of 6 were not rejected. I didn’t set running as Live.

Is Demo different than Live re TS min levels anybody know?

Thanks
GraHal
Author

Posts