Screener for market phases

Forums › ProRealTime English forum › ProScreener support › Screener for market phases

Viewing 11 posts - 16 through 26 (of 26 total)
1 2
  • 05/04/2017 at 9:52 AM #34499
    Marcel van Vliet

    Ok,

    This topic seems to be quite dead, pitty we can not come any further.
    @Grahal can you point me out how to get your flattened MA with % deviation, that will detect a Stage 1 and 3 on my charts?

    Thank you ……

    05/04/2017 at 2:03 PM #34515
    Nicolas

    Stages 1 and 3 would only be identified once the market has been already in a price range since a while. It would also be the case for stages 2 and 4 though .. So how do you jump into a trade at stage 2 or 4? What is the trigger? Breakout of recent highest high or lowest low?

    05/04/2017 at 2:16 PM #34516
    Marcel van Vliet

    I think the flattened MA with % deviation from Grahal is worth to test it. It must be possible to find any given MA on any given timeframe that stays flat during stage 1 and 3.

    My entry trigger depends on the price action of that moment. This can be a breakout, a (50%) retrace or a often used candlestick setup. As long as it fits my entry trigger criteria it wil do.

    05/04/2017 at 3:19 PM #34530
    GraHal

    For some kind soul (like Nicolas, although he is much overworked!) to code up a Strategy for us we need to define criteria. (I know you know this Marcel but it focuses both our minds?).

    The flattened MA I showed just happened to be on my Chart I think it was a MA(60) and x % deviation should be a good Trade entry point during a horizontal Range / Stage 1 or 3.

    So let’s keep it simple, to get the ball rolling?

    • End of Stage 1 or 3 Entry:        x% deviation from MA(y)
    • Existing Stage 2 Entry:             Breakout from HH
    • Existing Stage 4 Entry:             Breadown from LL
    • Exit at any Point:                       Failure to make a HH or LL (double top or bottom).

    Retracements often start and finish with a double top / bottom, especially on lower TFs?

    We can add to above as we go along, for example dojis, haramis and more?

    GraHal

    05/04/2017 at 5:13 PM #34563
    GraHal

    Hi Marcel, in an earlier post you say … my English language is too poor to translate the coding manual … if you use the Chrome browser and right click you can select the option to translate from and to any language.

    Technology is wonderful 🙂

    GraHal

    05/04/2017 at 8:11 PM #34572
    GraHal

    Re above / the ‘Guide Translator’ … it was just a thought so we can amend / add to any System together without using up others valuable time?

    Also I just realised that you were originally asking for a Screener. What you reckon … we go for an Auto-Trade Strategy then we can Backtest and see if our ideas are any good!? 🙂

    GraHal

    05/04/2017 at 8:35 PM #34574
    Marcel van Vliet

    The main idea was a screener indeed, because the phases have proven to be consistently profitable for a long time. It would help me a lot if a screener determs the phase any given stock CFD is in. My research time, beside my trading and writing activities, is too limited to concentrate on developing a full strategy. I will help where possible and I guess with the screener I will save time to invest in the development of the strategy.

    My latest idea about the flattened MA with % deviation is to add 4 colours, so when a phase is changing the colour of the MA will change as well. Usable?

    05/04/2017 at 10:24 PM #34579
    GraHal

    I guess the problem with coding a Screener is … what stage of the Stage 1, 2, 3 or 4 is the code looking for / defining? A Screener can only check a single bar at the time of running the Screener.

    You mention …  add 4 colours etc … a Screener either ‘pulls’ or not? How do you see colours as part of a Screener? Or are you thinking of an Indicator?

    Even if we went for an Indicator which marked up /  labelled a Chart with Stage 1, 2, 3 or 4 then I would think it’s a very clever man who can do … particularly as we are not very forthcoming with definitions / criteria?

    I thought an Auto-Strategy might be easier to code? May get some ‘output’ from this Thread?

    GraHal

    05/05/2017 at 12:09 AM #34583
    GraHal

    I said above … screener can only check a single bar at the time of running the Screener … which is not correct.

    But a Stage / Phase Screener would need to decide which Stage (1 – 4) the bar that just closed is part of?

    Wow … it’s more complex than I thought … you agree Marcel?

    GraHal

    05/05/2017 at 8:29 AM #34598
    Marcel van Vliet

    Yes, it is complex to translate the maket phases to a screener, but if we take a step back, you mentioned pretty good criteria,

    • End of Stage 1 or 3 Entry:        x% deviation from MA(y)
    • Existing Stage 2 Entry:             Breakout from HH
    • Existing Stage 4 Entry:             Breadown from LL

      To capture phases 1 and 3 we can think of using the PRT automated support and resistance lines and maybe tweaking those  lines to later defined criteria.
      As for the colours I think a coloured version of the MA wil do.

    08/27/2022 at 1:36 PM #199714
    jonpt88

    Too bad that this topic never resulted in an indicator? Looks super interesting.

    2 users thanked author for this post.
    avatar Marcel van Vliet, avatar GraHal
  • Author
    Posts
Viewing 11 posts - 16 through 26 (of 26 total)
1 2

Find exclusive trading pro-tools on ProRealCode Marketplace

Similar topics:
screener based on another screener
screener for the market with description
3 week screener rsi
bearish rsi screener modification?
best stocks & etf screener
bladescalper indicator and screener : updates backtests and customizations
checking daily criteria in an intraday screener possible?
crsi screener code
do the market replay reports actually work?
ema logic screener errors

Create your free account now and post your request to benefit from the help of the community
Register or Login