Trading without indicators

Viewing 15 posts - 511 through 525 (of 529 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #266211 quote
    shugshug
    Participant
    Senior

    If playing with your strategies to make them better; I know it might seem obvious but just a note, focus on why and when the drawdowns are happening and take them out the equasion. if it means no trades on fridays, or between certain times then try that because its made a massive diffrence to some of my systems, also id the drawdown is happening lets say fridays and your trading system is buying on fridays try testing selling on fridays and eny other days thats eating into your profits! simple but very very effective as i have found out.

    The very worse thing thats eating your profits can be the best thing thats ever happened to you if you turn them off or do the opposite with them.

    #266212 quote
    GraHalGraHal
    Participant
    Legend


    shug wrote: time based entry, time based exit
    1. You are referring to time readings on a clock – right?
    2. You are not referring to time / bars that a trade is open / trading?
    #266214 quote
    pableitorpableitor
    Participant
    Master

    Maybe I’m missing something, but what’s the actual difference between trading on a Friday or any other day ? Especially when you’re scalping on the 1–5 min charts?

    #266218 quote
    shugshug
    Participant
    Senior

    yes GraHal my trades can be on for 5 minues up to 4 hours (holding time before closing them). if for example i have a trade on with a trailing stop and its not automatically took out by a certain time then it automatically closses the trade, could be before half past 1 or 14:30 or any other time depending on the asset im trading or the system i’m using.

    Pableitor; my backtests showed clearly most drawdown happend on a friday for example i have the option of dont trade on fridays or do the opposite trades and see if i can cap those losses or gain more points, as for the 1 – 5 min charts yes I can set a time limit on those just as easily as a 15 min or 30 min chart for example a quick momentum scalp at open or news items can be that way.

    everything is time and price related, nothing fancy just what im seeing on the charts over time

    GraHal thanked this post
    #266224 quote
    shugshug
    Participant
    Senior

    no indicators involved in any of my tests or systems i have running and as you can see they clearly genarate profits

    Screenshot-2026-11-13-083946.png Screenshot-2026-11-13-083946.png us30_equity_curve-scaled.png us30_equity_curve-scaled.png Screenshot-2026-11-13-083648.png Screenshot-2026-11-13-083648.png Screenshot-2026-11-02-181612-scaled.png Screenshot-2026-11-02-181612-scaled.png dax_equity_curve-scaled.png dax_equity_curve-scaled.png
    #266228 quote
    shugshug
    Participant
    Senior

    Don’t take anything at face value its all just tests over time to give you/me an idea of consistancy over certain periods of time, even then everything has to be tested live at some point for another period of time to get confidence in it. A lot of the tests i have done with automating my trades has dragged my % win rate down to 70% because i generally just run them on the live account at very little a point to see how they actually perform, if there doing well i put more on per point if they slowelly eat into profits i stop them and do more tests to see were the leaks are then test them again after making modifications. I’m no expert with this stuf I just like a challenge and i get board doing the same thing day in day out. Im actually more focused on my anti gravity project that im building, thats the same, test change modify and try again, not expecting miricals but its all good fun! i like spinning objects LOL

    #266229 quote
    shugshug
    Participant
    Senior

    I can hear the silent internal thoughts, FFS, i thought that guy knew what he was talking about with trading now hes talking about building an antigravity machine LOL

    GraHal thanked this post
    #266230 quote
    shugshug
    Participant
    Senior

    Life is too short, got to have a bit of fun now and then its not all about making money although money sure helps!

    #266231 quote
    GraHalGraHal
    Participant
    Legend

    In your screenshot, copy attached. it refers to a Trailing Stop of 10 and a max loss of -10 … are you saying you do not let any trade exceed a loss of 10 points?

    So if using a trailing stop (TS) then the TS activates at 10 points gain and the trade exits if price crosses back under that TS?

    2026-11-13_11-41-48.png 2026-11-13_11-41-48.png
    #266233 quote
    shugshug
    Participant
    Senior

    not all systems im testing have a 10 point stop or trailing stop, 10 points is a really tight stop. or trailing stop, used properly at the correct times its useful but remember take these numbers with a pinch of salt until properly tested under real live conditions, i don’t trust results until i go live and even then its minimal amount per point

    #266234 quote
    shugshug
    Participant
    Senior

    I use quant dat manager to download tick data and i’m not sure how accurate this is and i run through python that information and do my tests then use AI then test in prorealtime backtests then hit go live if they still look ok to trade


    GraHal thanked this post
    #266235 quote
    shugshug
    Participant
    Senior

    sometimes the numbers are well out of sinc from what they should be, i don’t have a lot of trust in these things but other than that i don’t have many other choices if I want to run tests over time to find out ‘something’ and turn systems into automatic systems. my best results i can get manual trading still out performs my auto systems but there based on observations/momentum price and time in the moment if you know what i mean

    #266236 quote
    shugshug
    Participant
    Senior

    I know you like the small timeframes ‘seconds’ so your at the snakes head upfront ‘in the moment’ I can do the same thing on 5 min or 1 min and its just bacause of the screen time i put in over the years, consciously or unconsciously you build a really good intuition that in my opinion has an advantage over any automated system but that an opinion based on experience

    #266237 quote
    shugshug
    Participant
    Senior

    As your aware I don’t like taking notes on my trades i know i should but i dont. but some things i do i can’t explain its like my heads attatched to my finger and it clicks the buy or sell without me thinking because my brain knows whats happening at that moment in time, if i was to stop and think about it then it interupts the process and doesnt get me in at the right time, sounds crazy i know but its the way it is and i cant give that instruction to any ai or anything else. if i don’t know the program running inside my head how can i accuratelly tell any program what to do

    #266238 quote
    shugshug
    Participant
    Senior

    the reason i don’t just stick to that process is that when doing this i can take up to 100 trades a day which is draining, its actually soul distroying and its no life. Sitting in a trance like state click click click 5 days a week jeez oh not for me. people don’t realise there brain inside there head is amazing and learns things even when your not aware of them. There is an internal proccess happening but the moment you become aware of it the focus shifts and mistakes happen. I’d say instea of giving any AI information, give it to your brain instead by spending more time on the charts until your brain understands the market then try trusting your instincs, even starting with small capital, when the lightbulb goes off and you see results dont get too excited and don’t go questioning things try and just let it happen without interupting things

Viewing 15 posts - 511 through 525 (of 529 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
ProRealAI ProRealAI New

Stuck on this ProBuilder code?

Describe what this topic is trying to build, in plain English, and ProRealAI writes the ProRealTime™ indicator, screener or system for you.

Available in 7 languages
Try ProRealAI

Trading without indicators


General Trading: Market Analysis & Manual Trading

New Reply
Author
author-avatar
shug @shug Participant
Summary

This topic contains 528 replies,
has 24 voices, and was last updated by shugshug
1 week, 2 days ago.

Topic Details
Forum: General Trading: Market Analysis & Manual Trading
Language: English
Started: 07/30/2020
Status: Active
Attachments: 128 files
ProRealCode ProRealCode
Loading...