Trading without indicators

Forums ProRealTime English forum General trading discussions Trading without indicators

  • This topic has 356 replies, 16 voices, and was last updated 2 months ago by avatarshug.
Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 357 total)
  • #140624

    Advise from me is: Don’t go into the market with the intention of winning every trade, this will come of its own accord with experience (conscious competence).

    Don’t knock yourself for the losing trades either as this is part and parcel of the nature of learning, I think its a must as no one is good all the time BUT they get better in time.

    Acceptance of the losses is just part of the journey, how you ‘deal’ with the losses can set your journey back many miles. Very difficult I think for Someone with a formed belief in something to change so quickly to something else so an open mind is good to have.

    Please don’t believe anything I say as You need to test for yourself in order to form your own belief if you want to do as i do in the markets.

    Not so long ago I had so many indicators on my chart I couldn’t see the price! So many lines at support and resistance and pivot points and fib lines and time frames, how the heck I didn’t manage to go bankrupt i’ll never know.

    Keep things simple as possible! The price is the price is the price, its not an ‘indication’ of what might or might not happen in the not too distant future.

    Just a point to keep in mind also: There are people out there making good livings off of indicators! I just haven’t found there method or indicators and the ones I tried didn’t give me good enough results consistently so I changed then my results changed.

    CONSISTENCY great word!

    #140626

    I know there are a few good traders in this forum and they use different methods of extracting money out of the market and I don’t want anyone thinking my method is any better than there’s. Its just ‘another’ method, that’s all! Everyone has there own preferred method or system. This is just what works for me and if you can make it work for you then my jobs done. I have no systems for sale, all information is free of charge, i wouldn’t dream of selling any trading system/method to anyone I don’t need to. I actually get benefit if I can help someone just knowing that they are doing well in life and trading.

    I do feel strange talking about manual trading in a code forum so thanks for not blocking me out!

     

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    avatar ALE
    #140627

    That forum section is there for this kind of topic, so it’s a pleasure to welcome good topic about trading experiences,  wherever they come from 😉

    If you don’t mind,  I think that people, me included,  would love to get trades examples with screenshots! Have a nice weekend.

    #140628

    Thank you Nicolas

    What I intend doing at some point is using a video screen recorder like camtasia studio or similar to record a video session of the trading, then I can upload it to let people see on the screen where and when I’m going on and off my trades. I don’t have the program but I have used it in the past for recording. If I  can get the program I’ll do that.

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    #140629

    Great! Much better! Looking forward to see it. Thank you.

    #140646

    So I take it you don’t wait until the end of a 3 minute bar to open or close a trade?

    We may as well try and automate your strategy?

    It probably won’t work as an auto-system  as. like me, you likely don’t follow exactly the same procedure each time?

    When we see your video the coding wizards can see if it can be automated! Sounds fun! 🙂

    #140675

    A very high % of my trades do not happen at the beginning or end of the 3 minute bar its a really good chance its in between, I don’t watch the bar counting down (too busy watching the move). I’m currently trying to get video capture software sorted on my computer (shouldn’t be long). I start work between 3am and 4am and i’m usually finished roughly 10am. Its a customer based business I purchased about 8 months ago witch currently has 600 customers in my area. We were seriously hit by this covid 19 thing and had to close the business for 7 weeks because our customer base are mostly over 70. I work 7 days a week and trading is second to the business at this time. I have 38 kids out delivering to the customers and my job is feeding them the orders and keeping track of changes all day long so trading has to be in between doing this. I’m 49 now and hope not to be doing this business for 10 years or more so I have to make enough from trading to retire early enough to enjoy a bit of life. I don’t have a lot of savings to fall back on so I stay very careful with amount risked on my trades. £1 a point is fine with me for now, when I reach £10 a point I should make good enough money each day to save a decent enough amount and I’ll pay someone else to look after the business and let that tick over in the background to cover any losses I might have in the markets while still making money at my leisure on a beach somewhere lol

    Well, nothing wrong with dreaming

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    #140680

    Sorry I’m a nosey beggar, I have to ask shug  … what are old folk ordering that they could live without during lockdown?? 🙂

    It can’t be ready meals?

    #140691

    Newspapers and magazines

    #140692

    I sell roughly £4000 worth a week so they are in high demand

    hence the early starts!

    1 user thanked author for this post.
    #145227

    Hi, did you have the chance to record a trading session?
    Regards
    R

    #145534

    Shrug.

    Thanks for your input.
    Seems me and you use the same strategy and have the same mindset.
    Price action is the main indicator. MA20, MA50, MACD and RSI are the only indicators I use.

    Take profit before the market turns against you. “Rather lose out on amove than lose” . There will be days when the market moves a lot and profits double or more.

    I only trade Indices because one can gauge the market movement by comparing the price movement from other Indices.
    ie: If FANG move then NASDAQ will go same direction. If US500and RUSSEL2000 moves then DJI will move same direction. If EU Stox move then FTSE and DAX will move the same.

    I listen to Bloomberg and CNBC the whole time. Valuable information feeds. Stay away from the market if the FED has some announcement and wait for the market to take direction after.
    With the US elections coming up there is no market direction indication so short time frame trading/scalping is what more people do now. Most traders interviewed on Bloomberg/CNBC says the same thing. Buy the dip – take profits – wait for the next move – small profits in the bag – while keeping eye on longer moves. The US market in general will settle after US elections.

     

    2 users thanked author for this post.
    #147551

    Thanks Shug for your tips.

    Would it be possible to reach you by email or similar?

    xxx @ xxx

    Edit by moderator : Please see rules in yellow box below, no personal info such as email address or phone numbers in the forum, thanks

    #150945

    wow shug, really interested in that video!

    #202641

    Hi my friend I see your still at the trading! good stuff I hope your making loads of cash. I’m just back myself after quite a long time, just started trading again, I only trade US30 now, back at the scalping stuff. here is my results from my last 7 days scalps (attached).

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 357 total)

Create your free account now and post your request to benefit from the help of the community
Register or Login