Ehler’s MESA indicators constantly reload/recalculate?
- This topic has 19 replies, 6 voices, and was last updated 5 years ago by
.
-
Stocks & Commodities V. 36:03 (8–11): Recursive Median Filters by John F. Ehlers
Impulsive noise spikes or extreme price or volume data are not unusual in the nancial markets and these extreme values can throw off your averaging calculations. How can you set up a data lter to re- move these extreme price movements? This STOCKS & COMMODITIES Contributing Editor shows you a way to handle this by using a lter that discards all data except the median value.
Median lters are best applied to remove impulsive or spiking types of noise. Rather than averaging the spike into the lter out- put, median lters simply ignore the spike. Median lters are routinely used for pro-
cessing photographs and video because they preserve the sharp edges in the images rather than smoothing them as is done by averaging lters. Median lters have the unique characteristic of being idempotent, that is, if you repeatedly perform median ltering on a time waveform, the output rapidly converges to being exactly the input waveform except for com- putational lag. That a price waveform converges to a core waveform has some interesting philosophical rami cations for trading.
HOW SO?
Median lters are nonlinear. Since a median lter is not a convolution lter, it cannot be suitably represented in the Fourier frequency domain. Also, its output is not differentiable and therefore does not have a Taylor series expansion. This precludes curve- tting by a higher-order polynomial.
There are many academic articles describing rather arcane algorithms for recursive median lters. The rea- son I consider the algorithms arcane is they exclusively study nite impulse response (FIR) types of lters.
This is because the applications being considered are being implemented in hardware rather than software. “Recursive” means using a previous calculation in the current calculation.
APPLYING IT
An example of a recursive lter used in trading is the exponential moving average (EMA). I propose a recur- sive median lter for trading be implemented as the EMA of a ve-bar median lter. A simple pseudocode representation of a recursive median lter is:
Output = a*Median(Input, 5) + (1 – a)*Output[1];
The EMA a is a constant between zero and 1. I prefer to calculate it in terms of the critical period of the lter. The critical period is where shorter wavelengths are passed by the lter and longer wavelengths are rejected at the lter output. The relationship between the EMA constant and critical period is expressed by the equation:
a = (Cosine (360 / Period) + Sine (360 / Period) – 1) / Cosine (360 / Period)
where the arguments of the trigonometric terms are in degrees.
An easier-to-remember approximation to the re- lationship between the EMA constant and critical period is:
a = 5 / Period
MORE FILTERING
An interesting and unique oscillator-type indicator can be cre- ated from the recursive median lter by further ltering with a second-order highpass lter. The highpass lter removes the DC (constant) values and very long wavelength components from the recursive median lter output. Using a second-order lter guarantees attenuation of the long wavelength components resulting from the statistical fractal pink-noise spectral shape of market data.
The second-order nature of the highpass lter reduces its critical period about 70% relative to the critical period of an EMA lter. The EasyLanguage code to compute the recursive median oscillator is given in sidebar “EasyLanguage Code For Recursive Median Oscillator.”
You can see the uniqueness and novelty of the recursive median oscillator when you compare it to the RSI (Figure 1). The recursive median oscillator is displayed in the rst sub- graph and the RSI is plotted in the second subgraph. The RSI is scaled to swing from -1 to +1 instead of the standard swing from zero to 100. The price data for Figure 1 is of the SPY for
the calendar year 2017. The recursive median oscillator uses a 40-bar (two-month) critical highpass period and the RSI uses a standard 14-bar calculation. Both indicators have a smoothing lter critical period of 16 bars. From Figure 1 you can see that the recursive median oscillator has less lag and generally has faster response to the larger moves in the price data.
SMOOTH AND EFFICIENT
When data contains impulsive noise or uctuations in data, a trader needs to gure out how to smooth that data with the least amount of lag. The recursive median oscillator meets this need by ltering out outlier data, which gives a better view of the bigger picture.
S&C Contributing Editor John Ehlers is a pioneer in the use of cycles and DSP technical analysis. He is president of MESA Software and cofounder of StockSpotter.com. MESASoftware. com offers the MESA Phasor and MESA intraday futures strategies.
The code given in this article is available in the Article Code section of our website, http://www.Traders.com.
(See our Traders’ Tips section beginning on page 48 for commentary and implementation of John Ehlers’ technique in various technical analysis programs. Accompanying program code can be found in the Traders’ Tips area at Traders.com.
The EasyLanguage code to compute the recursive median Filter is given in sidebar “EasyLanguage Code For Recursive Median Filter.”)
1 user thanked author for this post.
Hi Bard,
I advise to send a technical report by following these instructions:
– As soon as you encounter the issue, go to the “Help” menu on the ProRealTime toolbar.
– Click on “Technical support”
– Select “Code”
– Giving as many details as possible, explain the issue you are having in the text box and mention the name of the code you are referring to.
– To receive in depth assistance, it is necessary to analyze the code itself which is encrypted on our servers. To allow our technicians temporary access, please check the box marked “I authorize the decryption of the codes…”
– Click “Send report”This will send a report containing technical information concerning your platform, which will allow the technical team to run a diagnostic analysis of the issue you have come across.
Many thanks in advance,
Ulrike
1 user thanked author for this post.
Dear Bard,
Our technical team confirms that the problem with the Ehler’s MESA indicators has been resolved. The last test on the DOW instrument in 4 hours timeframe and with 1 000 units did not show any recalculation.
If the situation occurs again, please send us a technical report following these instructions:
– As soon as you encounter the issue, go to the “Help” menu on the ProRealTime toolbar.
– Please assure that the window concerned by this issue is open.
– Click on “Technical support”
– Choose the category (e.g. “Data” for a spike)
– Select the concerned window in the drop-down menu.
– Giving as much detail as possible, explain the issue you are having in the text box.
– Click “Send report”Best Regards,
1 user thanked author for this post.
Find exclusive trading pro-tools on 
