Pathfinder Trading System

Forums ProRealTime English forum ProOrder support Pathfinder Trading System

Tagged: 

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 1,835 total)
  • #13717

    The DOW result is impressive but there are also a couple of higher losses.

    Pathfinder DOW V4

     

    #13730

    So a little play with V4 IN/OUT sample. Jan 2009 – March 2014.

    Actually picks out first and third MA as 2…

    Bit choppier than your version with MUCH more drawdown, overall result slightly better but prefer your version. I think it proves that your version is solid…?

     

    #13740

    in backtest the version 4 seems better results for the DAX and the FTSE 100 while Wallstreet looks no better. I noticed that putting as 8-23 transaction time is improved a little.

    #13744

    Cosmic1, Thanks for your confirmation. It’s good to know that DAX V4 works reliable and without big drawdowns before 2013.

    #13751

    Miguel, You are right. In Pathfinder DOW V4 the new variables maxPositionSizeLong and maxPositionSizeShort have the wrong values (3) and limit the result. Please change the values to 15 and you will see a comparable V3 result. I have attached a comparison of V3 and V4. Sorry for the confusion.

    #13763

    Hi Reiner, DOW not looking so pretty before 2012.

    If you want to ping me a message on email travel141 at gmail dot com I can give you skype details if you want to throw any code like this at the extended data I have if that would help?

    #13774

    Hi Reiner,

    Great work!

    I have been running v3 live since Sept 19 and it opened a long position on Sept 26 17 pm, but the backtest did not, unless I limit the starting date and time to Sept 19. Is there anything I should think about before starting v4?

    Regards,

    David

    #13775

    Hi Reiner,

    Disregard my post above. I had forgot to set the correct no. of units to show in the backtest, so now both show the same.

    Regards,

    David

    #13780

    Perfetto. Tutto ok Reiner.

     

    #13782

    Hi Reiner,

    I’ve been following your progress over the last few months and its been really impressive.  I only put it on a live demo account in the last few weeks.  How have things matched up in relation to the backtest and live testing/trading since you started.

    I know you have talked about this in a previous post but I think this is the topic everyone is keen to find out about.  Many of my simple strategies produce fine results on PRT but when it is a complex piece of coding it concerns me that the live results and backtest may be quite different.

    Thanks for all your effort,

    James

    #13789

    Cosmic1, Thanks for DOW backtest and your offer. I appreciate your support for this project and will come back to you.

    #13802

    No worries.

    IN/OUT optimise with 10 years of data. 2.8 Spread.

     

    2 users thanked author for this post.
    #13805

    Miguel, I have tested  your idea that Pathfinder avoid intraday reopen a position in the same direction. Please find attached the comparison of both backtests with DAX mini. Your idea is valueable!

    Here is the code, changes are tagged with #Miguel:

     

    #13811

    Hi James,

    Pathfinder is a completely transparent project from the first idea up to the current state every step is documented here in the forum. The backtest with the DAX seems to be realible over the last years but to be honest I have no idea whether such a system realy works under real condition. From mid of July until now I traded several versions V2, V3 and now V4 but not continously and the return is more or less zero. An automatic trading system needs volatility and a trend to make money and over the last month DAX was a “lame duck”. It requires hundreds of trades to realy judge a system and requires a lot of patience. In a 4H timeframe it will take a time (months).

    I’m not a professional trader and I’m far away to be a professional trading system developer so every idea, reniew and improvement from the real pros are welcome.
    best Regards,
    Reiner
    1 user thanked author for this post.
    #13817

    Perfetto Reiner.

    if you enter  definendo intra dal trading window 8-23. ….  Incredibile more

    miguel.

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 1,835 total)

Create your free account now and post your request to benefit from the help of the community
Register or Login