Hi all,
After running my own strategies live, I’ve learned the hard way that a good backtest can still blow an account. Not because the code is wrong, but because of how the results get read.
The big one: a backtest that starts in 2010 isn’t the same as going live today. Early profits build a buffer, drawdown % is measured from a much bigger compounded balance, and with indices several times higher, the same contract size carries far more leverage now. A “15% max drawdown” can mean losing most of a small account if you start today.
So I’m offering free tests for strategies posted in this thread. For each one I’ll run:
- Fixed size over the full history, not compounded
- Multiple markets and timeframes, to check the edge isn’t a one-off
- Drawdown in £ per contract at today’s index levels, and the minimum account size that implies
- Key stats: profit factor, max drawdown, win rate, average trade, number of trades
- A plain verdict: robust, fragile or overfitted
Post your code or rules plus the instrument and timeframe, and I’ll post the results back here so everyone can learn from them.
Zac