Dax Open – Long Short Strategy
Please see that thread.
A bit reluctant to post because someone worked hard on this, and I don’t mean AI-vy. But, my comments should be useful; helpful.
My estimate : 90% bloat which only confuses.
Very hard to read. Assumes knowledge of terms which a beginner clearly does not have. One could attest that this is to learn from though. However, now it only causes unnecessary hurdles first.
Programming style is not-conform hence does not adopt to how “we” tend to work.
Comments are -as usual- on the exact wrong subjects.
As usual, Comments are off base. Example : One entry per day per direction. This does not apply to the code as a whole and whoever asked for this, will not understand (it does not apply two directions at all – only one).
Requires an Intraday chart. No, it requires a 1 minute chart or seconds that can be divided on the minute (like 1, 2, 3, 5, 10, 12, 15, 20, 30). Am I overdoing it ? … if people are supposed to learn from this then maybe I am not.
The applied “logic” seems to have been derived from Wim’s post. This is dangerous because who knows what Wim really knows. For fun : I do. But this takes more than copying text from him (which is what happened here).
The logic of the programming language is not followed. Or at least has been insufficiently followed. The If shortDone = 0 is a typical example of that (we’d use If Not shortDone).
Because numerous examples exist that would make such a code really decent and readable, it is clear (to me) that this will be the opposite to learn from; you’d rather learn the wrong things.
I don’t like her face, but that could be personal.
She could do a good job as Moderator; would save a lot of copy-paste from Roberto.
There will be more to find, but for now this should be sufficient.
It will be a very long time before AI-vy really can be used. Let her stay ? also fine. But you can expect more and more blunt responses from people (like me), just how chatting with AI really goes. It will be the only way which could help, but I think never with several forces at the time (more than one teaching person). This could be an interesting discussion in itself.
So @AI-vy, what do you think yourself ?
